Live Better
 
 

Do placebos still work if you know you’re taking them?

New research suggests the relationship between our mind and body may be even stronger than we thought.

For a long time, researchers have known that unknowingly taking a placebo can have very real, positive impacts on someone’s symptoms. However, recent research from Harvard Medical School has shown the power of placebos may go a step further, and potentially benefit patients even when being taken knowingly.

The placebo effect

When a new medication is trialled in a clinical setting, it’s common for half of the test subjects to get the real drug, and the other to get what’s called a placebo. The placebo contains no actual medicine, being used to help researchers understand the degree to which the real drug works. The subjects typically do not know whether they’re taking the real thing or not.

You may have heard of a medical phenomenon known as ‘the placebo effect’, where up to a third of people taking a placebo will experience relief from their symptoms. There’s been a lot of research into how the placebo effect works, physiologically and psychologically, but not as many studies done on whether knowingly taking a placebo could improve your health. Common sense would say no, wouldn’t it? You might be surprised.

Promising placebo studies

A French study in 2010 found that patients knowingly taking a placebo for Irritable Bowel Syndrome experienced improved symptoms for the duration of the 21 day trial, as opposed to a group undertaking no treatment, placebo or otherwise. Researchers found a clear association between improved quality of life and open-label placebo takers, with improvement and relief from symptoms even documented to the level of the most powerful IBS treatments available.

More recently, a 2016 study at Harvard University found similar results, concluding that knowingly taking a placebo may be helpful in treating chronic lower back pain. All patients were taking existing pain management medication, but the group taking additional labelled placebos experienced a more significant reduction in pain. Even more surprising was that 17 patients requested a prescription for placebos at the end of their trial.

Harnessing the power of placebos going forward

In the past, it was thought that placebos relied on deception for the patient to experience real benefits, but these studies indicate this may not be the case. What we do know is that further research is required into the interaction between placebos and human psychology to fully understand how they work, but who knows — maybe soon it could be possible to manage certain symptoms with nothing but placebos and the power of your mind.

Check out more expert advice on staying well here.

Recommended Reading

Health Insights

How to maintain strong and healthy bones

6 simple tips to reduce your risk of osteoporosis . Read more

Health Insights

Can too much stress lead to a bad heart?

The negative effects of constantly being in fight-or-flight. Read more

Health Insights

Medibank trialling haemodialysis in the home

Giving members with chronic kidney disease more choice. Read more

Health Insights

Innovating for members living with chronic disease

CareComplete is supporting members to manage their health. Read more

Health Insights

Medibank’s chemotherapy in the home trial

Working towards more choice over where you get treatment. Read more

Health Insights

How do I know if my child is a healthy weight?

It's not always easy for parents to recognise problems. Read more

youtubetwittersign-up-userArtboard Copynp_phone_503983_000000download_red4xdownload_red4x copyArtboardmember-offer-starLogoMedibank - Logo - ColourOval 5Instagram iconicon-editdownload_red4x copygive-back--spinesgive-back--moneygive-back--massagegive-back--likegive-back--jointgive-back--emailgive-back--dislikedownload_red4xdownload_red4xGroup 5filter-iconfacebookMobile Navcheckcarret-upcarret-rightcarret-leftcarret-downGroup Copy 2arrowarrow-circleanimated-tick