Will the real superfoods please stand up?

What's a ‘superfood’, really? An expert examines them to see which are worth the hype

Forget about the humble apple a day keeping the doctor away – if marketing hype is to be believed, we need to be loading up our diet with superfoods to give us superhealth. Some of the best foods to be eating, however, lack this marketing hype, but they do deliver on their health promises.

What is a superfood?

The word superfood is a widely used term, common on the internet and in the marketing of exotic (and normally expensive) fruits and vegetables. But what exactly constitutes a food being labelled as ‘super’?

‘Superfood’ has no meaning among nutrition scientists – the people who know the most about the science of food. The word also has no legal definition, so anyone is free to market any food they are promoting as ‘super’. Superfood is more an over-used marketing tool than a useful guide for consumers in choosing what foods to eat.

Putting the lack of a solid definition aside, closer scrutiny shows that any food labelled as a superfood will normally describe a food with a high content of nutrients that can offer health benefits. Examples of such nutrients include antioxidants, fibre, selenium, zinc and the healthy omega-3s oils. Not surprisingly, most of the superfoods are fruits or vegetables – foods which, when looked at collectively, certainly merit the super title and would be endorsed as such by any nutritionist.

 

“Superfood has no meaning among nutrition scientists. The word also has no legal definition, so anyone is free to market any food they are promoting as super.”

Some of the foods that are commonly promoted as superfoods include:

  • Blueberries
  • Broccoli
  • Garlic
  • Quinoa
  • Wheatgrass
  • Tea
  • Goji berries
  • Soy
  • Kale
  • Noni juice
  • Coconut oil
  • Mangosteen
  • Spirulina
  • Acai
  • Pumpkin seeds

All these foods can be good to eat. The real differences between them though are not their nutrients, but the amount of marketing spin, overblown health claims and price.

Just one example is the claim made about wheatgrass shots being nutritionally equivalent to one kilogram of vegetables. Such a claim is total nonsense. The nutrient composition of wheatgrass is similar to an identical serving of broccoli or spinach. In fact, a single floret of broccoli, or a tablespoon of spinach, will contain more folate and vitamin C than a shot of wheatgrass juice.

Superfood fail

Antioxidants are the most common nutrients focused on in in the promotion of superfoods. So how do the turbo-charged antioxidant claims made about some superfoods stack up? In 2007, CHOICE measured the antioxidant levels of a range of different samples of goji, noni, and acai juices. These juices are heavily promoted for the health benefits they give, arising from the high level of antioxidants they contain.

The results of testing were damning for superfood antioxidant claims. Compared to the antioxidant content of a Red Delicious apple, all of the juices tested contained only between 10% and 30% the amount of antioxidant capacity of a regular apple – yet they were sold for many times the price.

 

“High in fibre, loaded with nutrients, and containing minimal calories, cruciferous vegetables give you real bang for your nutritional buck.”

Top superfoods to consume

So what are some core staple foods that are easily and cheaply found at the supermarket where there is good evidence of real health benefits? Here are my top five.

1. Cruciferous vegetables

Vegetables in this family include broccoli, cauliflower, kale, turnips, Brussels sprouts, bok choy, and cabbage. High in fibre, loaded with nutrients, and containing minimal calories, cruciferous vegetables give you real bang for your nutritional buck. The strongest research evidence points to regular eating of cruciferous vegetables being protective against cancer development.

2. Mixed nuts

Nuts are an excellent source of protein, healthy fats, fibre, and vitamin E. Eating a handful of nuts each day is linked to a lower risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes and can help manage weight.

3. Tea

Tea is rich in flavonoids which have antioxidant, antimicrobial, and possibly cardio- and cancer-protective effects in the body. Both black and green tea appear to offer health benefits.

4. Berries

Blueberries are a common ‘pin-up’ superfood, but there is plenty to be said for the entire berry family. Cranberries, raspberries, strawberries and even goji and acai berries (as whole foods, not the expensive juice supplements) are all great to be eating more of for their fibre and antioxidants.

5. Oats

Oats are a good source of protein and B-group vitamins and are low in fat. The type of fibre in oats can lower cholesterol and help control blood sugar levels.

What it all means

Because there are thousands of natural chemicals present in foods, there is no single food that should be called a ‘superfood’. Instead, think ‘superdiets’ that contain plenty of different plant-based foods as the best way to eat for good health.

What is a ‘superfood’, really? Professor Tim Crowe takes a close look at these nutrient-packed morsels, and which ones are worth the hype.

 

Recommended reading - Issue Sixteen Winter 2016

Recipes

10 ways to enjoy sweet potato

Bursting with flavour and vitamin goodness, sweet potato is a comforting veggie staple.

Read more
Experts

8 things you should know about preventing disease

How can you lower your risk of common health conditions?

Read more
Recipes

Roasted guinea fowl, brussels sprouts, baby beets and quince recipe

A deliciously juicy dish, full of flavour and colourful veggies.

Read more
Community

How your blood can change lives

Blood is a precious resource. Here's why we should all consider donating to people in need.

Read more
Experts

10 ways to reach your running goals

Go the distance and seamlessly achieve your running goals – while protecting your body from injury.

Read more
In Brief

CareComplete: Support for chronic health conditions

How Medibank helps members with chronic health conditions take positive steps forward every day.

Read more
Travel

The best bike-friendly cities

Discover the most bike-friendly cities of the world.

Read more
Community

The healthy food gap

There is not just a healthcare gap in Indigenous communities, but a healthy food gap too.

Read more
Lifestyle

The history of the stethoscope

Brilliant ideas often spring from unlikely places, like the playful history of the stethoscope

Read more
Experts

Caring for braces

Braces will be your best friend (once they’re off your teeth). Here’s a few tips for the meantime.

Read more
Community

Onsen Ma: Soaking and shiatsu

Healing steam from the Japanese mountains settles in the Melbourne laneways Onsen Ma.

Read more
Experts

Eating for a healthy heart

Make heart-friendly food choices for a healthy heart by following these simple guidelines.

Read more
Recipes

Lamb shank and vegetable soup recipe

Need a new soup recipe? This hearty lamb soup beckons with bursts of fresh vegies.

Read more
Lifestyle

Winter bike riding tips

Tour De France winner Cadel Evans tells you how to keep bike riding through the winter months.

Read more
Recipes

Spicy pumpkin and lentil soup recipe

Spice up your soup ideas this winter with a pumpkin and lentil soup inspired by Indian flavours.

Read more
Experts

What pro athletes really eat

Learn why you don't need to make drastic life changes to eat a healthy, balanced diet.

Read more
Experts

Laser eye surgery alternatives

Laser surgery not an option? Here are some alternatives.

Read more
Recipes

Corn fritters with tangy tomato salsa recipe

These cajun-flavoured corn fritters with tomato salsa will freshen up your weeknight routine.

Read more
Lifestyle

Healthy school lunchbox ideas

Healthy kids are happy kids with this innovative school lunch ideas.

Read more
Experts

A guide to good guts

Protecting your gut bacteria with healthy food is vital to overall health.

Read more
Experts

What are macronutrients?

So what exactly are macronutrients? We've got the lowdown.

Read more
Lifestyle

7 easy ways to get active in winter

Take a look at a list of activities to keep your heart racing during the dreary winter months

Read more
Recipes

Curried cauliflower salad recipe

A curried cauliflower salad recipe for something a little fancy.

Read more
Recipes

Lentil soup recipe

Lentil-based dishes like this red lentil soup are not only delicious but are packed with goodness.

Read more
Experts

The best immunity-boosting foods

Want to avoid the dreaded flu this winter? Try these immunity-boosters to strengthen your defenses.

Read more
Recipes

Chicken and white bean casserole recipe

Try this fresh and protein-packed chicken and white bean casserole with pasta or extra vegies.

Read more
Experts

10 tips for diabetes-friendly food

Top ten food tips to manage or prevent diabetes and enjoy a healthy life.

Read more
Community

Hit 100: Diabetes-friendly eating made easy

Hit 100 takes the frustration out of diabetes-friendly eating for a happier, healthier life.

Read more
Recipes

Pea and ham soup recipe

Try this take on a classic soup by seasoning with Himalayan pink salt.

Read more
Experts

10 things you need to know about the body

Our bodies are complex, mysterious, miraculous things. Dr Bridie O'Donnell tells us how they tick.

Read more
Lifestyle

Your quick-start guide to running training

Whether you're gearing up for a marathon or your first 5 km, prepare your mind, body and wardrobe.

Read more
Experts

How to build mental resilience

Life has a habit of testing our limits - mental resilience is your chance to bounce back.

Read more
Experts

Exercise for mental health treatment

Anxiety and depression can be exhausting, but exercise is one fantastic way of fighting back.

Read more

For full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable JavaScript. Here are instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your web browser.