5 reasons not to cut grains from your diet

Fibre-rich whole grains are vital to a balanced diet. Accredited Dietitan Tim Cassettari explains

If you have heard about the low-carb, gluten-free or Paleo diet, you have likely heard the idea that removing grains from our diet is beneficial for our health.

While we do benefit from limiting our intake of refined grain foods, such as white bread, refined cereals, white rice, biscuits, cakes and pastries, this is not a good reason for removing grain foods altogether.

Here are five reasons why.

1. Fibrous grains are often very nutrient rich

Fibrous grains, which include wholemeal breads, high-fibre cereals, wholemeal pasta, oats and barley, are minimally processed plant foods that provide not only fibre, but magnesium, zinc, B vitamins, vitamin E, resistant starch and an abundance of different antioxidants too.

While we often think of grains as empty calories, this is far from true. Grains are the leading contributor of seven key nutrients in the Australian diet today.

2. Science tells us that fibrous grains promote good health

Yes, among other things, grains do contain carbohydrates, and a high carbohydrate intake can impair weight loss and lower good cholesterol, increasing heart disease risk.

But research time and again tells us that people who eat fibrous grain foods:

  • Have better heart health
  • Have better metabolic health
  • Have better intestinal health
  • Are better at managing their weight

Clearly, there is much more to fibrous grains than just carbohydrates, and not all carbohydrates are bad for our health.

“By remembering that grains are neither good nor bad, and by focusing instead on eating the healthiest amounts and types of grains, we enrich our diet with vitamins, minerals and antioxidants.”

 

3. These health benefits cannot be made up easily from eating other foods

The main health benefits associated with fibrous grains are actually significantly greater than the associations seen with even that of fibrous fruits and vegetables. This has been shown consistently for a lower risk of:

  • Heart disease
  • Diabetes
  • Bowel cancer
  • Weight gain

While fruits and vegetables are of course important, it is most difficult to achieve optimal health with just the fibre from fruits and vegetables alone.

4. Most of us are not eating enough fibre-rich grains 

There is no need for grains to be the foundation of our diet: just 40-50 g of fibre-rich grains a day is commonly thought to be enough for these significant health benefits to develop over time. To put this into perspective, this amount is only slightly more than 1 slice of wholemeal bread, or 1 bowl of oats. We don’t need to eat a lot.

The issue though is that most of us are falling short of even this small amount, and many people are now also reducing their intake further due to the popularity of overly restrictive low-grain fad diets.

5. Good nutrition is about moderation and balance, not the total exclusion of food groups or nutrients

The difficulty today seems to be in knowing how to separate quick fix fad diets from good, evidenced-based nutrition.

Perhaps it is worth remembering, then, that while fad diets usually sell an idea of all or nothing, good nutrition promotes the concepts of moderation and balance, with an understanding of the range in which the healthiest balance actually lies.

By remembering that grains are neither good nor bad, and by focusing instead on eating the healthiest amounts and types of grains, we enrich our diet with vitamins, minerals and antioxidants, and promote better health, too.

In nutrition, very rarely does the healthiest balance exist only at zero.

Recommended reading - Issue Three Autumn 2013

Lifestyle

Getting kids into sport

We take a closer look at some of the best sports programs for kids.

Read more
Experts

Boot shopping

Tips to choose the right boots this season.

Read more
Experts

Use it or lose it

Activities to keep your brain fit.

Read more
Experts

Chinese medicine for the four seasons: Autumn

Advice to maintain good health from summer to autumn.

Read more
Community

The role of an optometrist

Optometrist Julia Kapov explains how an optometrist can help you on your journey to better health.

Read more
Community

The joys and challenges of trail running

Matt Cooper delves into his love and knowledge of trail running.

Read more
Lifestyle

The perfect apartment dog

They don't shed hair, they don't bark, and they don't need much space. Meet the Italian Greyhound.

Read more
Lifestyle

Finding the purrfect feline friend

A few things to keep in mind when considering a feline addition to your household.

Read more
Travel

Cherry blossom season

We've picked out the best spots in Japan to see these iconic flowers of spring.

Read more
Travel

6 things to do in Singapore

Bright, clean and colourful, the island city-state of Singapore is full of contrasts.

Read more
Lifestyle

The history of bottled water

A brief history of how we got so thirsty for bottled water.

Read more
Community

Xtend Barre

Merging the principles of pilates with the energy of dance delivers one serious sweat.

Read more
Recipes

Roast loin of pork with baked apples and quinoa stuffing recipe

This decadent roast is the perfect recipe for a lazy Sunday afternoon with family.

Read more
Lifestyle

Bad fad diets

A look at some of the worst fad diets that somehow managed to gain a global following.

Read more
Lifestyle

Bill Granger on stress-free cooking

Learn healthy habits and delicious recipes with Bill.

Read more
Recipes

Roasted apricot yellow couscous with grilled fish recipe

Bill Granger believes in a relaxed approach to good food. Here, he shares a family favourite.

Read more
Lifestyle

Marion Grasby on cultural and culinary diversity

Marion Grasby tells us what’s on the menu for her wedding.

Read more
Recipes

Thai prawn fried rice recipe

Inspiring chef Marion Grasby shares one of her favourite Thai dishes.

Read more
Community

Working out with Serena Williams

Tennis superstar Serena Williams shares workout tips for staying in peak form.

Read more
Community

Learning from crisis

How to rethink your priorities and recalibrate your moodometer.

Read more
Community

Big-hearted Clare Bowditch

Clare Bowditch talks mindfulness, meditation, and about being an ambassador for Smiling Mind.

Read more
Community

Deborah Hutton’s balanced life

Deborah Hutton provides advice on ways we can achieve balance in our lives.

Read more
Community

Chris Carroll – Walking for a cause

Medibank has a team of four walking 100km together to raise money for Oxfam.

Read more
Lifestyle

Food on the move

Run on solar power and vegetable oil the Veggie Patch Van is bringing healthy food to you.

Read more
Lifestyle

Literary (health) classics

“Be careful about reading health books. You may die of a misprint.” Mark Twain

Read more
In Brief

Move to Ikaria – fast

Frequent naps, no clocks and an abundant diet are the secrets to a long life.

Read more
In Brief

Cloning new teeth: say “Baaaa!”

70 per cent of adults aged 35-44 have lost at least one permanent tooth to decay.

Read more
Lifestyle

Visualising health with Jude Bolton

AFL footballer Jude Bolton has played 300 games and won two premierships with the Sydney Swans.

Read more
In Brief

Join in the fresh food fun

Get your hands dirty in the garden and learn how to prepare seasonal produce.

Read more
In Brief

Work-off a factor in food labelling

How long would it take you to work off your afternoon snack?

Read more
Lifestyle

Health Shelf – Andy Allen

Andy Allen gives us a tour of his pantry and shares some recipes from his new book.

Read more
In Brief

A spoonful of beans…

How beans and other legumes can help type 2 diabetes sufferers.

Read more
In Brief

Quantifying exercise

Researchers have made an incredible discovery about the effects of exercise.

Read more
Community

A juicy idea

How Emma and Tom’s small venture has grown into a big business focused on healthy products.

Read more
Community

Trail running gear

We recommend shoes, clothing and other gear that can optimise your trail running experience.

Read more
Community

Bound, leap and hotfoot it across the land

A quick summary of some great trail running locations across the country.

Read more
Community

Ambassador for a worthy cause

Haley Bracken, ovarian cancer ambassador, talks how to stay mentally and physically healthy.

Read more
Community

Double hat trick with Ellyse Perry

Athletic prodigy Ellyse Perry on balancing study, professional sport and life as a young adult.

Read more

For full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable JavaScript. Here are instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your web browser.